The care and protection of children today is regarded as vitally important to the nation, in stark contrast to the last century when one in every five infants died within the first 12 months of life.
It was not uncommon in the 19th century for whole families of young children to be wiped out by epidemics, especially as they were often weakened by poverty, malnutrition and long hours of labour in factories and workshops. Children had been employed and exploited in ever-increasing numbers in many factories and mills, being subjected to long hours, harsh treatment and inhuman conditions. Although the Earl of Shaftesbury became the champion of these children and was responsible for much factory legislation which limited hours of employment, child slavery took a long time to be abolished. It had been common practice in industry to have gangs of youngsters working day and night, much to the detriment of their health and welfare. It was not until 1918 that child labour was totally banned.
Living conditions in many parts of Birmingham had been unhealthy for most of the 19th century as the city became known as ‘the toy shop of Europe’, producing wares of all kinds in iron and steel, jewellery, guns, buttons, buckles and trinkets.
A good description of Birmingham at that time is given in Rev. Isaac Taylor’s Scenes in England for the Amusement and Instruction of Little Tarry-At-Home Travellers, 1822:
Oh, what a place are we coming to now? It seems as if it were all on fire; what a cloud of smoke rises in the air!
This is Birmingham, where the furnaces, and the glass-houses, and the steam engines, shoot up torrents of sulphureous smoke: where every workshop has its several chimneys, puffing up smoke, smoke, smoke, into the loaded atmosphere. Not only do the coals consumed darken thus the air, but gasses and fumes from metals, oils and varnishes, and every sort of manufacture, help not only to becloud, but almost poison the atmosphere.
Small wonder that generations of children grew up unhealthy, if they survived at all.
At the turn of the century countless children were too ill to take advantage of free education in elementary schools, many suffering from tuberculosis and associated diseases. In 1907 it was recorded that over 31,000 children died from the disease in England. Tuberculosis attacked the lungs, glands or bones, and frequently occurred when people lived in densely populated areas with unsanitary housing. By 1882 it was known that the disease was spread by coughing and spitting and the Germans developed the idea of treating patients in sanatoriums with plenty of fresh air and exercise. It was thought that many other children who were ill with anaemia and malnutrition might also benefit from such treatment.
In Britain the 1889 Report of the Royal Commission on the Blind, Deaf and others in the UK acknowledged that there was a need for ‘special boarding schools for pupils who were delicate or neglected’ but generally these children were regarded in the same category as those who were blind, deaf, diabetic, epileptic, physically disabled or mentally handicapped.
Children who suffered illnesses which were considered to be the result of malnutrition or poverty were classed as ‘physically defective’, along with other physically handicapped (but mentally normal) children who by reason of physical defects were unable to attend normal schools. The word ‘defective’ covered both mental and physical disability and replaced the term ‘feeble-minded’, originally used for educable children who could not be taught in ordinary elementary schools by the usual methods. Thus ‘defective’ could mean physically handicapped, educationally sub-normal or delicate (the latter term not generally used prior to the 1944 Education Act, when physically defective children were categorised as physically handicapped, diabetic or delicate).
The 1898 Report by the Departmental Committee on Defective and Epileptic Children revealed that at least one per cent of schoolchildren in London schools were defective, requiring special education, the main defects being caused by malnutrition or chronic illness.
There was very little education for defective children in Britain until the 20th century. Germany took the lead by providing schools in hospitals for the care of the crippled from 1832. In England the education of physically handicapped children dates from 1851 with the opening of the Cripples’ Home and Industrial School for Girls in London. Special schools in England developed as a result of the Elementary Education (Blind and Deaf Children) Act 1893 and the Elementary Education (Defective and Epileptic Children) Act 1899.
In 1898 Dr. Alfred Eicholz was appointed as one of Her Majesty’s Inspectors in London in the Education Department. He had a tremendous influence on special schools where many pupils who attended were delicate and underfed. Nine years before England’s first open-air school he advocated that physically defective children resident in special schools should have plenty of fresh air, dietary supervision and regular medical inspection, together with short lessons and lots of physical exercises and handicrafts. In 1903 he became responsible for the supervision of all the special schools in England and Wales.
The 1898 Report on Defective and Epileptic Children led to the Elementary Education (Defective and Epileptic Children) Act 1899, which allowed school authorities to make special provision for mentally and physically defective and epileptic children. As it was not compulsory this meant that 10 years later only a third of all authorities had made such provision. One of the inspirations of the 1898 reporting committee had been a school in the German town of Elberfeld which became a model for English special schools. It had been founded in 1867, being a school for the feeble-minded. It was later called a ‘help-school’, designed with short lessons of 20 minutes’ duration, and concentration on manual work or handicrafts, together with lots of ‘song and drill’.
At the time when the 1899 Act was passed education was still in its infancy in Britain. Out of 140,000 teachers in ordinary elementary schools only 62,000 were certificated and 26,000 had received no training at all. Children unable to attend ordinary schools because of physical illness were deteriorating at home, very often in crowded, damp and airless homes in city slums where there was little sanitation and an ever-present odour of decay from garbage, sewers or drains.
The birth rate fell at the end of the 19th century and a government report in 1904 revealed that only one in three potential recruits for the army was fit enough for active service. This report shocked the nation which realised it depended on the health of its schoolchildren for its future fighting strength. This lengthy publication by the Local Government Board’s Interdepartmental Committee on Physical Deterioration revealed to the public that a childhood of neglect and disease resulted in the physical deterioration of a whole generation. The report was to have a great influence on the future development of medical inspection of schoolchildren. There was also an increase in public opinion that some sort of education should be available for those children who were suffering from physical ailments due to poverty and malnutrition.
Dr. Eicholz gave evidence in the government report of 1904, recommending a system of special schools for semi-invalid children who were attending normal schools. The term ‘open-air school’ was not used but education in the countryside was advised, where fresh air and regular meals would revitalise and strengthen the children. Dr. Eicholz also considered that regular medical inspection of children in schools was the greatest single need in the school system. This was recommended in the report to be made compulsory for every school authority, together with school meals for malnourished children.
Germany had already appointed their first school doctor in 1883 and soon developed a very thorough system of medical inspection in their schools in the 1890s, much in advance of England. Backward children were treated in special schools and were given baths and hygienic instruction. In Britain the first school doctor was appointed in 1890 by the London School Board, followed by Bradford in 1893. Manchester opened the first local authority school for physically defective children in 1905.
Malnutrition was thought to be the major cause of poor physique, which led to the report by the Board of Education in 1905 on the Medical Inspection and Feeding of Children attending Public Elementary Schools. It was disclosed that only a few authorities provided any meals, and some of the meals were produced haphazardly by voluntary bodies. The resultant Education (Provision of Meals) Act was finally passed in 1906.
The need for medical inspection was stimulated in the following year, when the International Congress on School Hygiene met in London. The government took action with a clause in its Education (Administrative Provisions) Act 1907, compelling school authorities to provide medical inspection—but not treatment. The Board of Education issued circulars to local authorities on the aims of the school medical service.
The Local Education Authorities (Medical Treatment) Act 1909 led to the establishment of school clinics in the school medical service and the development of open-air schools. Thus the official School Medical Service came into existence, with the Medical Branch (later called the Special Services Branch) of the Board of Education, with Sir George Newman at its head. He was to have great influence on the development of the school health service, and by the time he retired in 1932 nearly 2,000 school clinics had been successfully established to save many children’s lives. He was a strong champion of the open-air school movement.
In 1907 Dr. Eicholz became responsible to the Medical Branch of the Board of Education for the supervision of all special schools, including defective children. He was later elected as the Chief Medical Inspector of HM Ministry of Education. Inspections of children revealed many dirty and verminous cases with a great range of diseases and disabilities. Ailments such as swollen adenoids and tonsils, rickets, incipient tuberculosis, ear discharges, and bronchial catarrh were often the result of unhygienic homes and unhealthy environment. Other common ailments were ringworm, measles, scarlet fever and diphtheria.
The only countryside many town children ever saw was on special outings arranged by charitable organisations such as Country Holiday Funds, Fresh Air Funds and Children’s Aid Societies which sponsored visits to seaside convalescent homes. The Children’s Country Holiday Society sent many children into the countryside for short holidays. In 1909 the Daily Mail Fund provided over 5,000 pairs of boots for Birmingham children and the Police-aided Association for Clothing Destitute Children provided over 3,000 pairs of clogs the following year.
Smoke pollution meant many city households sealed their windows at night and children rarely had fresh air. Dr. Caroline O’Connors, one of Birmingham’s first Medical Superintendents in Special Schools, reported in 1908: ‘one factor that keeps tuberculosis in flourishing condition is the dread of fresh air exhibited by the majority of people. In the houses of the poor, it is the rarest possible thing to find a window open. Yet some medical men ... certify tuberculous children as ‘unfit for school’ and one finds them shut up at home in a small airless back room ...’.
Fresh air and sunshine had been recognised as therapeutic for many consumptives since 1840. The open-air school movement was an adaptation of established sanatorium treatment for physically weakened children.
The first pioneer open-air school opened in Germany in 1904 in the pine woods at Charlottenberg, a suburb of Berlin. Pine trees, with their sweet scented vapours, were generally regarded as having a healing effect on throat and lung diseases. The buildings were of a primitive nature: a rest-shed open on the south side, two school barracks of five enclosed classrooms which could be heated in cold weather, two very large sheds open on all sides for lessons and meals, and small sheds dotted over the grounds, each accommodating four to six children. In addition there were slipper and shower baths and children spent their days out of doors.
It was designed as an ‘open-air recovery school’ for backward and debilitated pupils who were not so mentally deficient as to fit in with subnormal pupils. The children rapidly increased in weight and strength and many who had been seriously ill were entirely cured. Frequent meals amounted to almost forced feeding with five meals a day: soup and a slice of bread on arrival at 8am, milk and bread and butter at 10am, dinner at 12.30, followed by two hours’ rest, more milk and bread at 3pm and a final meal of soup and bread and butter at 6.45pm before being sent home.
Not only did children recover physically and educationally but ‘moral’ improvements were noted with regard to ‘cleanliness, self-help, punctuality and good temper, once they were removed from the influence of street life’, according to one contemporary source.
Reports on the success of the school stimulated the German school authorities to build open-air schools at Mulhausen (near Cologne) and Elberfeld in 1906 and 1907 respectively. At the time few educational innovations made such an appeal to the popular imagination as did these schools because many seriously ill children were cured.
The open-air movement had spread to England in 1907 when London opened its first school at Bostall Wood, Plumstead. In 20 acres of wooded grounds 108 debilitated children suffering from conditions of crowded city life were at school from 9am to 6pm, with porridge and milk on arrival. Lunch was provided, followed by biscuits and fruit at 3.30pm and tea which consisted of bread and butter and currant buns at 5.30pm. Mackintoshes were provided for wet days and ‘steamer chairs’ (deck chairs) and blankets for rest. The school was kept open for 13 weeks and all the children improved in health and spirits, as well as intellect. In 1908 the school transferred to a better site at Shooters Hill in Woolwich and two other open-air schools opened in London.
America followed suit in 1908 with open-air schools at Providence (Rhode Island) and Boston. In New York City a moored ferryboat was utilised for tuberculous patients along the same lines. In Chicago a successful open-air school opened in 1909 on a rooftop site where children thrived happily in severe weather conditions, well wrapped up in woollen clothing and ‘sitting-out’ bags.
Meanwhile, other English schools sprang up at Bradford and Halifax in 1908, followed by Norwich, Sheffield and Barnsley which marked a new chapter in preventative medicine. Margaret McMillan’s open-air Camp Schools proved a great success in Deptford, London. Some schools were in large houses with sheds in the grounds whilst others were of the simple ‘band stand’ variety, with canvas walls which rolled up in good weather. A typical timetable included breakfast on arrival, with lunch and tea later, interspersed with short lessons, rest periods of up to two hours and several short playtimes.
The contemporary writer, Leonard Ayres, in his book Open-Air Schools which was published in America in 1910, wrote:
It has been said that the two greatest discoveries of recent times are the value of children and the virtues of an open-air life. In the last few years there has been a wonderful public awakening along both these lines. There has been an enthusiastic reception which has been almost universally accorded to the open-air school which is an object lesson in the beneficial results of an outdoor life. It is too soon to prophesy what the future of the open-air school will be ... It seems not improbable that the open-air school will be recognised by future historians of education not merely as a therapeutic agent but rather as marking one long step towards the school of the future where the child will not have to be either feeble-minded, delinquent, tuberculous or truant to enjoy the best and fullest sort of educational opportunity. The keynote of the school work is constant change from work to play, reading, singing and rest, together with constant stimulation of interest.
From the beginning the British Board of Education had been very supportive to the new open-air schools and gave additional grants from 1912 (under the Medical Treatment Regulations) for the maintenance of the children. The extra grant of £3 per head was on top of grants made under the Blind, Deaf, Defective and Epileptic Acts for residential and day schools.
Sir George Newman summed up the way of life and the system of treatment in open-air schools with seven cardinal points:
1. Fresh air and sunlight
2. Proper diet
3. Rest
4. The hygienic way of life
5. Individual attention
6. Medical treatment
7. Special educational methods
Contrary to some popular opinions on open-air schools, life did not consist only of eating, sleeping and playing: it was not an everlasting picnic for children. The timetable required dedicated enthusiastic teachers able to carry out a curriculum of study at least three to four hours a day. Only children who were rated strong enough to learn were selected for open-air schools, despite disabilities due to malnutrition, anaemia, mild heart disease, tuberculous glands, nervous diseases such as chorea, adenoids and bronchial catarrh.
In many ways British open-air schools took the lead in modern methods of education, adopting manual instruction (learning by doing) which proved so successful with their pupils. Activities included weather study, paper cutting, metal work, woodwork, clay modelling, drawing, needlework, weaving and practical arithmetic exercises.
The requirements of an open-air school included a situation facing south, on the outskirts of a town which was within walking distance of transport. Trees or land was recommended for protection on the north and east and it was important that large trees provided shade for outdoor lessons. Children spent most of the time in the fresh air and some classrooms were specially designed with movable screens on three sides. As the majority of pupils were anaemic, sunlight and fresh air was considered essential for the cure. For this reason most classrooms were detached from the main building which usually included a dining hall, kitchen, medical room, bathroom, and administrative offices. Verandas were often built on three sides of the classroom, intended to be used for teaching in fine weather. In some schools slatted platforms were used outside for classwork.
Artificial heating was not envisaged, unless the temperature fell to 35°F as the theory was that children caught cold passing from warm rooms to the cold outside air. Children became acclimatised to the cold, having a better circulation than adults. Vigorous exercise was recommended before lessons and overcoats and rugs were used to retain heat. Every half hour children had further physical exercises, especially if snow blew in to the classrooms and ink wells froze.
Canvas and wood stretchers were generally used for rest periods and in cold weather extra clothing was worn. All countries providing open-air schools agreed that children had to be kept warm, preferably with woollen underwear and outerwear. In America each child was provided with a heavy overcoat and a ‘sitting-out’ bag made of blankets and canvas, cut and stitched to conform with the shape of the chair and attached to it by tapes. As these bags were expensive to produce Dr. Carrington of the National Association for the Prevention and Cure of Tuberculosis developed a cheaper product made of flannel, lined with cotton ‘batting’ and six or seven layers of newspaper. However, one of the main objections to the use of ‘sitting-out’ bags was that pupils were apt to regard them as ideal places to collect and secrete their childhood treasures—
including food supplied which they stored up for future use!
In addition each American child had two blankets, a knitted toboggan hat, warm gloves and ‘soapstones’ or hot water bottles in the coldest weather to keep feet warm. As the latter created problems with children’s footwear (often cracking cheap leather) felt shoes were often provided. Another device was a wooden foot-box lined with padding, into which was placed the soapstone or hot water bottle. Teachers were not forgotten either as they were provided with long wool or fur coats, a fur cap and mittens, felt shoes and a rug to protect their feet.
Pupils at English schools do not appear to have been provided with the luxury of foot warmers or ‘sitting-out’ bags. A photograph in Ayres’ book, which is reproduced here, gives an example of equipment provided for pupils at the open-air school in Providence in America in 1908. It is hard to believe that children were supposed to be educated whilst covered in so many layers of restricting warm clothing.
Regular baths and showers were regarded as most important in those days when few homes had such facilities to combat dirt and disease. The nurse usually regulated the shower baths from the side and they were intended as much for skin tonics as for hygiene. Hugh Broughton’s book The Open-Air School relates the usual procedure for showers at open-air schools:
The children strip and take up a position in line just in front of the spray rosettes. The nurse turns on the water ... When ready she blows a whistle and each child steps forward into the shower. After a moment the water is turned off, each child steps back and proceeds to soap the limbs. The water is turned on again and on the sound of a whistle each child steps into the shower. This is repeated twice, for washing of the limbs is followed by the washing of the trunk (the children help each other to wash the back) and finally the face and neck are washed. During the last shower the temperature of the water is reduced to lessen the risk of chills. The children should assist each other to dry themselves properly so that the nurse may give her whole attention to supervision.
Regular weighing sessions were held, together with breathing and physical exercises which strengthened resistance to disease. Breathing exercises formed part of the medical work for which teachers were often responsible. These were usually performed in the fresh air, sometimes as many as four times a day. This was to teach children to breathe properly, to improve blood circulation (which helped to eradicate disease) and to exercise the lungs. Speaking and singing often improved after such exercises. Deep breathing and diaphragmatic breathing were practised for the lower portion of the lungs as children often failed to breathe properly and became prone to diseases.
Spinal curvature was often a result of physical debility and exercises were also given by the nurse to children needing special treatment. Many children were given malt or cod liver oil and received treatment for discharging ears, bad eyes and other ailments.
Rest for two hours in the middle of the day, usually in the open-air, was one of the most curative measures in open-air schools. Many malnourished and anaemic children failed to thrive and to properly digest and absorb their food on account of inadequate sleep in crowded homes and poor living conditions. It became recognised that a good meal frequently generated a feeling of drowsiness, during which time of rest the whole of the available energy in the body could concentrate on the digestive system. Without rest, food often passed through the body without being fully absorbed, especially in anaemic children. Healthy growth was often impossible for many children if their food at home was inadequate or unsuitable and they had insufficient sleep. Deck-chairs were often used in the early open-air schools, although Birmingham was to pioneer the use of specially-made stretchers. To retain body heat blankets, bonnets, caps and mittens were supplied during school rest times.
Food was always a priority in open-air schools as so many children were poorly fed. At home many lived on bread, pastry, jam, fried fish, pickles and anything highly flavoured or filling, without regard to digestibility and nutrition. Plain nourishing food was provided at the schools and most children took full advantage of it, especially as fresh air sharpened the appetite. The result was always an improvement in physique and health at all the open-air schools.
Three meals a day at school was the norm—breakfast, lunch and tea. Porridge or bread and dripping was often served for breakfast and lunch consisted of such filling dishes as beef puddings, roast mutton, jam rolypolys and currant puddings. Beverages were usually cocoa at breakfast and tea at teatime.
There was a great emphasis on outdoor activities such as gardening, nature study, practical geography and dancing. It was, in fact, a completely different way of life and to be selected for an open-air school was considered to be a privilege and a unique experience for any schoolchild.
The British medical profession was generally in favour of open-air schools to combat the dreadful scourge of tuberculosis which affected the whole population. Successful sanatorium treatments had proved that fresh air, food, rest and cleanliness worked wonders. Medical officers were obviously hoping that such schools would more than pay for themselves by creating healthier schoolchildren.
Around this time Birmingham was considering housing reforms and the Open Spaces Association was discussing new recreation grounds for children and the general public. Suddenly the open-air issue had become very important. Birmingham had no open-air school, but the Education Committee viewed such schools with approval in its 1908/9 Report by the Medical Superintendent:
… the open-air school, which is the result of a compromise between the state, the parent and the physician, has passed beyond the experimental stage. Their utility has been amply praised by experience and the rapidly increasing number of open-air schools indicates the recognition that they form a necessary part of educational organisation ... and it should not be forgotten that fresh air is also necessary to healthy children in schools.
In 1908 Birmingham Education Committee had appointed its first Chief School Medical Officer, Dr. George Auden, a general practitioner from York. He became a leading light in the open-air school movement, referring to the development in Germany in his first annual report. One hundred and twenty applicants were interviewed for the three additional posts of School Medical Officers in the city. The successful applicants were Doctors Agnes Parsons, Lewis Graham and James Fenton whose duties were to examine schoolchildren medically and to advise parents of any treatment needed. They began routine inspections of 5-year-old entrants and 13-year-old leavers. There were no school clinics at this time, nor free medical treatment, and the most frequent defects discovered by the teams were enlarged tonsils and adenoids, dental decay, defective eyesight and malnutrition, in addition to a very high percentage of verminous infestations.
As a result of all these medical examinations Birmingham doctors and hospitals were inundated with requests for treatment and the Education Committee itself took on the responsibility of testing children’s eyesight and supplying spectacles. School clinics were soon opened to provide treatment and advice for simple ailments.
Dr. Caroline O’Connors vividly describes the dreaded plague of tuberculosis at that time in her report in 1908 on physically defective children in Birmingham:
There are 185 defective children in our special schools of which 50% are tuberculosis cases. Complaints are often made of the expense of educating crippled children. The air of a city contains a large number of infectious germs and most of us are only able to resist their infective activity by our strong vitality. Those of low vitality, especially ill-nourished and weakly children, fall victims to the germs scattered broadcast by this most disgusting and unnecessary habit of spitting, which seems to have become second nature to many men. The tops of some trams are in a disgraceful condition and the danger is multiplied by the new trams, which are enclosed above, as well as below, so that sun and fresh air cannot weaken the deadly bacillus of tubercle.
Such was the background to the development of open-air schools in England. Birmingham seems to have been rather backward in the provision of such a school within its special school system, probably lacking the appropriate finance for such a venture. With hindsight, however, the authority was able to draw on the experience and plans of existing open-air schools when the generosity of Barrow and Geraldine Cadbury enabled them to plan for a new open-air school in the city. Birmingham was extremely fortunate to have such enlightened benefactors who provided an establishment which completely changed the lives of so many schoolchildren.
History of the Six Nations Championship